March 9, 2024
Description
Regenerative compressors provide good pressure head and medium flow at low RPMs. I designed this one from scratch in Sketchup to play with the concept for potential CPAP cooling on my printer. It starts to build pressure head at fairly low RPMs, but it needs plenty of power! A torquey low-RPM brushless motor, or possibly even a beefy stepper motor, would be ideal, but a DC 775 motor works very well for higher speeds and doesn't cost much. A 12V 1-amp motor with a belt reduction to spin the impeller around 5-600 RPM is about as low as this will go for providing useful flow. A 12V 10A (peak) motor should be good for 1+ PSI of pressure head and 10+ CFM, depending on the RPMs and belt reduction. To date, I have measured maximums of 1.25 PSI (output throttled) and 11 CFM (output open) with a two-stage build at about 4300 RPM. As a bonus, it is fairly resistant to damage from inhaled debris, not that I recommend chucking stuff in it (or using it as a vacuum cleaner).
You can build one unit for a single-stage compressor, or you can stack multiple units on a common shaft for a multi-stage compressor that builds more boost. Check out this performance review!
IMPORTANT: this is a prototype and you must DIY your motor solution. I do not have a standardized or “best” recommendation yet, but a 10-Amp DC 775 that does 6k at 12V works quite well, and can be had on Amazon for US $20 or less! You need something that will be happy and powerful in the 2k-6k+ RPM range, so this is not a job for a super high-RPM motor unless you use a belt reduction. The above-mentioned 775 motor specs run this compressor easily at 3:1 reduction (very little throttling versus load) for lower-pressure/CFM needs, or can run it at 1:1 and get about double the RPM, where it struggles more with loads and heats up but still pushes a lot of air. (Also, be warned that it SCREAMS over about 3K RPM without the silencer. I TAKE NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR HEARING. USE PPE!) A two-stage build can be driven nicely on 1.5:1 to 2:1 geardown with the same motor.
If you don't want to use a 550 or 775, but would rather go brushless, I would recommend creating your own motor mount for this. The casing has a mounting pattern of 6 M3x8mm deep holes on a 35mm radius. There are motor mounts provided for 775 (29mm M4 mounting screw spacing) and for 550-size DC motors (25mm M3 mounting screw spacing). Otherwise you can use the sliding mount and create your own motor mount (the M3 hole spacing is 24mm x 62mm).
Possibly the best power solution would be a heavy-duty stepper motor, like a NEMA 23, as one of the strengths of this design is its ability to perform across a wide range of input RPMs, but PWM-driven motors struggle to run quietly at the low end. However, I haven't tested this, and you would need to devise your own motor mount and control solution.
Printing tips:
READ THE STL DESCRIPTIONS!!!
Slice the impeller with “union overlapping volumes" because I couldn't be bothered to solid all those blades (sorry). I used 3 perimeters and 10-15% infill with fine results in PLA. For the housings, you only need support for the nozzle threads, so try to block it off from anywhere else. Otherwise, only the nozzles and accessory pipes need supports. You will need to embed 6 M3 nuts in each housing for the motor mounts; at .2 layer height, the best time to pause and insert will be around layer 22. A “nuts” warning will appear in the infill when it's about time to put them in!
There is a one-piece impeller included if you want to go the simple route, but it is NOT RECOMMENDED as it can't be easily tuned for flatness/centering. The multi-part impeller can be tuned for these. However, the prints require excellent print tolerances to fit together. Thankfully, you can iterate for a good fit with your printer by adjusting just one small part (the alignment ring) so you don't need to worry about having to throw away any big prints if they don't fit correctly on the first try.
For general assembly overview, especially for the multi-stage build, I strongly suggest watching the YouTube video.
MINIMUM prints and Hardware you will need for a single-stage build with the one-piece impeller and no silencer (but you do want the silencer):
RECOMMENDED intake silencer:
RECOMMENDED multi-part impeller print setup and hardware adds:
Multi-stage bonus hardware and prints:
Construction tips:
Make sure the impeller spins flat. For the one-piece impeller, You may need to trim the shaft hole and/or play with set screws to get it nice and aligned. There are peripheral pockets in the impeller to place M3 grub screws for balancing, but I didn't end up needing them. You may need to sand the interior air dams/rub lines to get friction-free spinning with the housing screwed shut. Use the provided spacers, stacked if needed, to get the clearance right. If assembled properly, you should be able to turn the housing and watch the drive shaft counter-spin as the impeller stays still inside. You will also need to drill or cut out a hole for the shaft on the housing side where you plan to mount the motor. Leave the other one capped off to avoid pressure loss! Finally, be sure to orient the impeller so the cupped blade surfaces are spinning away from the inlet. If you run it backwards, the performance will be worse.
ADDED 3.9.24: Here is a short video of my technique for dialing in the impeller flatness. There are shimming tips in the video description!
License:
Creative Commons — Attribution — Noncommercial
9